📋 Shiur Overview
Zohar Shiur, Erev Shabbat Parashat Vayetze – The Secret of the General and the Particular (Kelal u-Perat) in the Mitzvah of Faith and in Creation
Introduction: The Order of General and Particular in Knowing God as an All-Encompassing Order
Today is Erev Shabbat Kodesh (the eve of the holy Sabbath), Parashat Vayetze. I would like to say one thing, continuing what we have been learning about the first mitzvah in the Zohar. I think this will be the last shiur, or perhaps the second-to-last, on this mitzvah.
The words of the Zohar are as follows: there is knowledge of God in general, and there is knowledge of God in particular. And the Zohar explains, and this is the point we need to add here, that the order of general and particular (kelal u-perat) is a very comprehensive order, a very general order in the world.
We have already learned that the general and the particular, with regard to faith, are what we usually call “faith and inquiry,” or if you like, “knowledge and faith.” Although the word “emunah” (faith) does not originally mean this, in any case that is what it is called in ordinary language. Therefore the Zohar calls them “general knowledge” (da’at kelali) and “particular knowledge” (da’at perati).
And the Zohar says that this order was not born here for the first time (as we learned last week). For in general, the fact that there is a mitzvah, that there is faith and there are mitzvot, all of this, according to the Zohar, is part of the very same form and the very same order as the order of Atzilut (Emanation), the order of the sefirot, which are also built this way, in the manner of root and branch, a source and its results.
The General and the Particular as the Secret of Male and Female and the Building of the World
And just as this is so in general, so too in particular: within the mitzvah of faith itself, within the mitzvah of knowing God itself, there is a matter of general and particular, and this too is a fundamental order in the world. It is not merely something that was born here; rather, it is a fundamental order in the world.
And what is the fundamental order? The Zohar says: general and particular are themselves “reisha ve-sofa” (Zohar, Introduction 11b), the beginning and the end. Seemingly, as we learned, the beginning opens with the general, and in the end one gradually arrives at the particular; and it seems to me that afterward there is yet another general, something like “general, particular, and general.” And the Zohar says that this is the secret of “dekhar ve-nukva ke-chada” (ibid.), “male and female as one,” the secret of male and female. As we learned at the beginning of the Introduction, the secret of all the mitzvot is the secret of “Zakhor ve-Shamor” (Remember and Keep): “Zakhor” is the male, the positive commandments, and “Shamor” is the negative commandments, and it is the female, “Shamor for the female.” And the very same thing applies in particular to the mitzvah of faith: it too has male and female, it has an aspect of the female, and that is seemingly the place of inquiry; one of them is the general and one is the particular.
There is a great deal here, and he continues, and we will finish the line: “ve-eikh ka’im tadir bar nash be-hai alma” (ibid.), “and how a person constantly stands in this world.” A person in this world is occupied with general and particular. One should look for the source of the expression “occupied with general and particular,” as in “its generalities and its particulars are from Sinai” (Sifra, Behar, Parasha 1), something of that sort.
What a person does in the world is general and particular. And he says that the person himself is general and particular, and he seemingly means the male and female within a person: “bar nash be-hai alma havei kelal u-perat” (ibid.), “a person in this world is general and particular.” And likewise, “tikunei de-hai alma inun kelal u-perat” (ibid.), “the rectifications of this world are general and particular,” meaning the way the world is built; for “tikkun” here does not mean repairing damage, but rather the building of the world. The way the world is built is also by way of general and particular. Therefore, the fact that the mitzvah of faith contains within it general and particular is simply part of one single structure; that is how the structure of the entire world goes.
The Two Perspectives on General and Particular, and Their Connection to the 248 and the 365
The Contradiction in Understanding What Is General and What Is Particular
Seemingly there is a dispute here among the commentators, but it seems to me that this is not merely a dispute among commentators. That is, there is a contradiction here between two perspectives regarding what is the general and what is the particular, and I will explain this.
Seemingly it is like this: one way you can put it, and this emerges from several approaches here regarding servant and son, and regarding Shamor and Zakhor, is that in general the general is the general faith, and it is the aspect of the female, the aspect of faith; and as is commonly accepted, Malkhut (Kingship) is called “emunah” (faith).
And the particular is Tiferet (Beauty), it is the Torah, it is the particular knowledge; one can call it the 248 (ramach) positive commandments. It follows that the 365 (shasa) negative commandments also belong to the general, to the lower general, to the beginning. One begins from below upward, from the general knowledge, and afterward the 248, the particulars, the male, are the particular. That is seemingly the understanding, and that is seemingly also the order: when one goes from below upward, one begins from Malkhut and ascends to “Zakhor,” to the higher level, and Tiferet is the attribute of remembrance.
But in fact it seems there is also an opposite perspective here. We must see whether the two perspectives can be reconciled, and seemingly it is simple that they refer to different things. For when one learns these matters, one must understand their meaning; it may be the very same word, but it is used in the opposite way, and seemingly it also has an opposite meaning.
And let us add to the question that must be clarified here, what is general and what is particular, the matter of the 248 and the 365. For it seems that in this section of the Zohar, this is the last thing we must explain clearly. And in the next mitzvah the Zohar continues speaking about this, and we will continue speaking about it.
The Zohar’s Question: How Do the 365 Days of the Year Give Healing to the 248 Limbs?
The Zohar speaks here about the matter of the 365. Everyone knows that 365 are also the 365 days: there are 248 limbs and 365 days of the year. In other, later books it is written “365 sinews,” but in the Zohar not yet; and even in the Midrash and in Tractate Makkot it does not say 365 sinews, but rather the 365 days of the solar year.
The Zohar says that after the general come the 248. This seemingly fits with what we learned, that the 248 limbs, the positive commandments, are the particular, as we are seemingly saying. And afterward it says that once he has the particular, he should know as follows: “kedein yinda be-orach perat, de-da hi asvata de-khola” (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “then he should know by way of the particular, for this is the healing of all.” And just as we said regarding tikkun, so too “healing” should not necessarily be understood as curing an illness, but as building; healing is the help, the good, the health of everything. This is the particular knowledge: he knows each and every limb.
And afterward it says: “ve-yinda kol yomei shata de-mitchabran le-meihav asvata le-khol shayfin” (ibid.), “and he should know all the days of the year that join together to give healing to all the limbs.” And he himself raises a question; I saw that some versions have it and some do not have it at all, and whoever wrote this version, the question troubled him. The Zohar asks: “ve-i teima, kol yomei shata heikhi yahavin asvata le-khol shayfin” (ibid.), “and if you say, how do all the days of the year give healing to all the limbs?” What does it mean that the year gives healing to the limbs? And seemingly he does not mean simply to ask how this is possible; rather, he means to object that the matter is the reverse: if the 248 limbs are the positive commandments, they are the male, and the 365 are the negative commandments, time; and generally Malkhut is called “year,” and the order of times is the domain of Malkhut, the lowest division in the world, which divides into times, into past, present, and future. If so, it should be the reverse: vitality should come from the limbs to the year, not the year giving vitality to the limbs!
The Influence and Blessing Between the Limbs and the Days of the Year, Above and Below
And he answers: No, this is how it is: “vadai hakhi hu eila ve-tata” (ibid.), “certainly it is so above and below.” That is, both in the upper sefirot, or if you prefer, both in Binah (Understanding) and in Malkhut, and this must be understood well, there is such an order that the year, “shata ve-yomei dilah” (ibid.), “the year and its days,” give healing to the limbs above. And this must be understood. Perhaps one of the approaches we often learn regarding the arousal from below (itaruta de-letata) and the arousal from above (itaruta de-le’eila), how there is a reversed order, applies here; but perhaps there is something more here, and one must contemplate this further. I am keeping it short today, since this is the eve of an early Shabbat, and that too is in the aspect of “the days of the year” whose connection must be understood.
In any case, the Zohar says as follows: when the limbs pour out and bestow blessings upon the year, then a higher abundance rises upon them, and that is seemingly how “mi-le’eila” (ibid.), “from above,” should be interpreted, and this comes from the year: “man garim leih, yomei shata” (ibid.), “who causes it? The days of the year.” And he says that so it is also above, meaning in the partzufim (configurations) of Atzilut. Here too he seemingly follows the approach that the limbs are above the year, except that when they do so, the abundance comes from even higher days, from a higher level that is also called “year.”
And he says that so it is also below, and let us begin from below; perhaps this will make it more understandable: when a person completes his body with the 248 mitzvot, “leit lakh kol yoma de-la atei le-itbarkha” (ibid.), “there is no day that does not come to be blessed,” the days come to be blessed from him, and this is seemingly the meaning of “And Abraham was old, coming into days” (Genesis 24:1). And then, when the days are blessed from him, life and healing come upon him himself from above, and all of this comes from “the days of the year.” Just as the days of the year are blessed and receive abundance from the secret of the person, which is the 248 limbs, so they are; meaning the days themselves receive, and likewise below, the days receive abundance from the person.
So there is a real contradiction here between the beginning of the Zohar’s passage and its end, and perhaps there is some error here, a version in need of correction. But I will say what seems to me to be the two perspectives one can understand, and perhaps this will resolve it. And afterward there is a third thing that requires further contemplation, which is the connection between the day and the person. This seems to be an important matter, and the Vilna Gaon (the Gra) speaks about it in several places, and it is connected to the entire order in the world of circles (iggulim) and straightness (yosher), of male and female, of man and nature, and so on.
The First Perspective: The Male Is General and the Female Is Particular
The Parable of Man and Woman, and Chokhmah and Binah
I will first say this: there is one view that says the male is general and the female is particular. What does this mean? It seems to me this applies more to Chokhmah (Wisdom) and Binah than to Ze’ir Anpin and Nukva, Tiferet and Malkhut. The explanation is well known, but I want to explain it. This is one direction, and let us assume that in a certain sense it is also true of Tiferet and Malkhut. And let us say as follows:
As it says in the Midrash, what is the difference between man and woman, between Adam and Eve, between male and female? The man brings wheat home, he brings the general thing, and the woman details it: she does the grinding, the baking of bread, the work of the home. The work of the woman, as we see and learn in Ketubot, is spinning, spinning the goats’ hair; whereas herding the goats, bringing the goats themselves, is the work of the men. And the women divide the matter; granted, spinning is more a matter of joining, but in any case she takes something unprocessed, something raw, one big lump, such as wheat, and makes from it not wheat but bread, and challah, and cake, and so on.
And this is what we always learn as a parable for Chokhmah and Binah: Chokhmah is the general knowledge, and Binah is what details, what breaks the matter down into small parts and explains each thing on its own. And so too regarding time, regarding the days of the year that we are always explaining: time is the order of learning. Chokhmah is the general knowledge (as we learned at length in the Sefirat HaOmer shiurim, and this is not the place), the flash of insight, the clarification; and not necessarily the flash, but the clarification, the clarity that the matter is so, grasping the thing all at once. And Binah is what takes time. Another way of putting it: Binah is like the practical halakha. There is a principle, there is an idea, there is a lamdus (conceptual analysis), and from it one derives that consequently in this case the law is such; and that is the particular. One can call it the formulation, the detailed expression, and in this sense the particular is a descent; the particular is lower than the general. This is the approach that says, and this is seemingly how the Gra explains here at the beginning of the discussion, and I saw that he explains it this way in other places too, that the man is called general, the male is called general, and the female is called particular.
The Person as the General and Time as the Particular
The particular is the unfolding into details of the general. Like a rebbe and a student, who are also in the aspect of male and female: the rebbe states the great idea, the great vision, and the students, the gabbaim (attendants), must break it down and say that consequently it means that today such-and-such must be done; they draw up a plan, step by step, how to carry it out. Or as we say regarding explanation: one adds explanations, parables with details, questions and answers, all of which take time. This is one way to look at general and particular, and according to this approach it is seemingly understood that the particular is the lower thing.
How does this connect to the 248 and the 365? It seems to me that it does not connect, since the 248 and 365 are an entirely different matter. That is, if you look at it this way, you would say that the person, let us say the person within time, when one says simply “a person” and not 248 individual limbs, a whole person, is already a general. One thing: the person is a general thing, a whole thing, he is alive. And a living creature is something that cannot be divided, as we learn in the laws of Eruvin and elsewhere; a living thing is a unified thing, one thing, one person.
Now the person lives within time, and this is the sad condition of man. That is, in the World of Truth the soul does not live in time; and perhaps even the soul does, but in any case above the soul, Chokhmah, the intellect itself, does not live in time; it is above time. But the person lives in time. And what does it mean that he lives in time? That I can hold an enormous vision, I can understand everything, the entire world, in one moment; but in practice, in order to carry it out, I have to learn Daf Yomi, one page a day, one chapter per day, “one prince per day, one prince per day” (Numbers 7:11), as we will soon be saying at the beginning of the Chanukah reading; each day one thing. That is the person, and that is the meaning of the person exerting influence within time. The person is the general, and time, the 365 days of the solar year, is the particular.
This does not fit so well with the matter of the negative commandments, since the connection of negative commandments need not be “don’t commit sins at this time.” But the particular is the lower level. And by “lower” I only mean that it is more detailed; “lower” here is not a term of disparagement, but rather this is the unfolding into details: the man comes with a great plan, and his wife details it, takes it, and so on.
This is the one view of general and particular, and it is a comprehensive order in the world. For the creation of the world itself is like this: the Holy One, blessed be He, created light and darkness, and later, little by little, more separation came about, more details. And so too man in relation to the world, in relation to the Holy One, blessed be He, is also like this: man takes the work of God and details it. That is the tikkun that man performs, as the Arizal taught, that the tikkun is to divide the matter so that there are more vessels and more lines, more details. Man takes the great existing light and divides it, like a manager who divides up the work, who takes a big thing and divides it into small parts, and so each one receives his role. That is the role of man.
And this is also the role of Malkhut; the true role in general belongs to the sefirah of Malkhut. That is, all the sefirot above it innovate things, bring the general principles relative to Malkhut, and Malkhut, “and she gives food to her household” (Proverbs 31:15), distributes onward in a particular way. She understands that today this must be done, and tomorrow that must be done. All the distinctions and all the details belong to the sefirah of Malkhut, to the female part, to the lower part.
A Novel Insight: The Negative Commandments as a Matter of Time and Unfolding into Details
One might think that the matter of the negative commandments is connected to this in this sense, and I will now say a novel insight (chiddush). What does the matter of negative commandments have to do with time? A chiddush occurs to me.
Everyone knows that negative commandments mean bad things (as we have learned at length, and this is not the place to elaborate). But the truth is that there is no such thing at all as “bad things”: “The Lord made everything for His purpose, even the wicked for the day of evil” (Proverbs 16:4). All things in the world have a purpose. “And God saw all that He had made, and behold, it was very good” (Genesis 1:31); and this is the end of the work of Creation, the six days of Creation: everything is very good. “‘Very good’ – this is the evil inclination” (Bereishit Rabbah 9:7), meaning that even the evil is included in “very good.”
If so, what does it mean that there is a “do not”? Everyone knows that the meaning of a negative commandment is something not in its proper time. Like the roots of the negative commandments, for example keeping Shabbat, that on Shabbat it is forbidden to do work, or on Pesach it is forbidden to eat chametz (leavened bread). And one asks: is chametz bad? Is work bad? Work is good; the labors are “to do” (Genesis 2:3), to rectify. The labors are what the Holy One, blessed be He, Himself did in the world, and the creation of the world is a good thing. Shabbat does not say that the creation of the world is a bad thing; it says only that it has a time. And time is like a place, meaning it has a certain limitation. It has a time: all week one should work, and on Shabbat one should not work; all year one eats chametz, and on Pesach one does not eat chametz.
And in general all the negative commandments, as one learns regarding the secret of the sin of Adam, “she ate it unripe” (Bereishit Rabbah 19:5): all sins are nothing but “eating it unripe.” And as they said, “Rather than eat it forbidden, eat it permitted” (Beitzah 4a), and therefore they said, “something that will become permitted is not nullified” (Beitzah 3b). And in this sense, according to the secret, all transgressions are things that will become permitted. And further: why is it called chazir (pig)? Because it is destined to become pure. And stringency is the reverse: the more severe things are the ones that have more permissions, just as something that will become permitted is not nullified. What until now could never be permitted must now be permitted, a way must be found for it, for it must arrive, since everything has its place and has its role. Things that tomorrow will be permitted: “rather than eat it forbidden, eat it permitted.” And what is the main point? This is one of the tasks of man, and it is time: to set things in their proper time.
So one can say that the negative commandments are nothing but the detailer and organizer of the mitzvot. The positive commandments are the rectifications, the male, what the person does. And what does his wife come to say? The male is the thing that sows, that acts, that builds, that begets children. And what does his wife say? Beget, but with me; beget today, this way and not that way, with all the laws of forbidden relations, and likewise fundamental prohibitions: not with this one, not with that one, not today, not like this.
That is the negative commandment: it is nothing but time, nothing but a matter of time. But moreover, one can still view the “do not,” the Nukva, as separation. That is, she says: you have a good idea, but not today; or: do it today. She says: you want to learn all of Shas? Very good, divide it into days. That is the female. Daf Yomi is the female, and knowing all of Shas is the male. And if someone says the reverse: today is Tisha B’Av and one does not learn, then today is like a negative commandment; but in any case it is an aspect of the very same thing: set the matter in time. This is one perspective on the female, on the particular and the general.
How the Order and Limitation of the Female Bring Greater Abundance to the Male
And according to this perspective, which appears many times in the Zohar, the general is the male and the particular is the female. This is one more way that one can understand it. And according to this you will understand that seemingly the main thing is that the male is the giver, but the female can say that she accomplishes something. She adds; she does not add creation ex nihilo (yesh me-ayin), but rather the order of things, the detailing, the unfolding into details, the formulation, the particulars. People speak of “attention to detail”: generally most men do not like to deal with details, and in certain crafts, in handiwork, women prefer more to pay attention to the details. That is the order of things. This is just human psychology, but it is built on the very same idea.
And regarding this one can also say, if one wishes, and perhaps this is the simple meaning (peshat) of the Zohar’s words, and in this way one can also understand the matter: that although in essence the female does not innovate anything, “leit lah mi-garmah kelum” (Zohar I 181a), “she has nothing of her own,” she nevertheless produces a great innovation. That is, when there is no time, when a person does not keep Shabbat, he has no life, and he does not even have the whole week. Why? Everyone knows that when there is no time for rest, he will burn out and the like, in all the ways we explain.
So the fact that the female organizes, that a person has a daily schedule, and the daily schedule is in the aspect of the female, brings greater abundance. And this is a great secret. Although seemingly there is a certain limitation in this, since the male always wants to bestow, to innovate, to flash new insights every moment, nevertheless the fact that there is a certain order is what brings about the “yoma arikhta” (the long day). Although one can say that this is the lower level, it is what enables the higher level to function as well. And as we always learn regarding blockage: when there is the flow of a river, if it is blocked at its end, it will stop from above as well. Therefore, if there is order, and everything reaches its place properly, like the fountain that people have for the kiddush cup, which is a depiction of the attribute of Malkhut, where the wine flows into many small cups, then one can pour from above, and it pours from above properly. This is one approach to the matter.
The Second Perspective: Faith Is the General (Female) and Knowledge Is the Particular (Male)
The Difference Between the Order of Learning and the Order of Reality
But what we have been learning all along until now, we learned the opposite way, and it is simply a different perspective, one aimed at something else, with a different meaning. One could call it “the masculine within the feminine” (*zachar she-be-nekeva*), I don’t know; I only want to convey the different understanding, and the different understanding is something else entirely.
Let us return to the matter of faith (*emuna*). When we speak about faith, when we say that faith is knowing in a general way that there is a God, that there is a Master and Ruler, that there is One who oversees, and the like, that is called “faith.” And then knowledge says: fine, but how? What does the Holy One, blessed be He, do on the first day? What does He do on the second day? So to speak. This is the study of the Work of Creation (*Ma’aseh Bereishit*). One could say that Shabbat is the general knowledge that the Holy One, blessed be He, created the world, whereas what one learns from the first day onward, that is, how it actually works, the knowledge of the Work of Creation and the Work of the Chariot (*Ma’aseh Merkava*), is the detailed knowledge.
And now we must consider whether this meaning is on the same level as the previous meaning or not. That is, the question should be put this way: certainly, in this sense we are now speaking, let us say, about a kind of difference between the order of learning and the order of reality. The order of learning here is: certainly, someone who knows only in a general way is much weaker, and one could say that this is the aspect of the feminine (*nekeva*). And one could even say: why does he know only in a general way? Because that is his stage. He is young, and a young child is taught only “*Baruch Atah Hashem*” (Blessed are You, God) in its simple sense, and when he grows up he will learn more; so it is a matter of time.
Moreover, it is the feminine that arranges for there to be general knowledge in the world, and not because there are generalities in the world. You must remember that, in short, there is a contradiction here: the general (*klal*) is truly the highest knowledge; the Holy One, blessed be He, so to speak, is the general knowledge, the Holy One, blessed be He, is all-powerful and entirely unique. When we say that the particular (*prat*) is higher than the general, that is relative to us. That is, when we tell children “*Baruch Atah Hashem Emet*” (Blessed are You, God, Truth), the words include everything; but the child knows nothing of this, and therefore it is called merely general knowledge.
A Person’s General Knowledge Is Itself a Particular
And when he grows up he will have detailed knowledge, of the 248 limbs, the 365 sinews, and so on. And with all that, this does not mean that the level he is on now is the level of the general. He is not on the level of the general, nor even on the level of a lower general; sometimes this is called a kind of mirror, a reflection, in that the lowest general resembles the highest general, one could put it that way. But the truth is that right now he himself is a particular.
That is, there is a particular mode of conduct, and it is connected to the fear of God (*yirat Hashem*): “a woman who fears God” (Proverbs 31:30). Fear, part of fear is limitation; Rabbi Nachman says: not today, do not break through beyond your level, and the like. Fear is what the woman says; his mother taught him: today you will believe. He says: today I will believe. That is, the “today,” the aspect of day, and the contraction (*tzimtzum*), and the small level you have, and the fact that this is only general knowledge, all of this is itself a particular.
Thus the general knowledge that we call “general,” where seemingly the general is higher than the particular, contains no contradiction. For the general knowledge we call by that name is truly itself a particular, a great particular. And conversely, you might say that someone who knows more already knows the general; but it is not really that he knows the general, rather that he knows more particulars. One must understand that this is something different.
That is one way to understand it. That is, one can understand in one way that general knowledge, that “a woman who fears God,” is itself something real, and it has a real level called the particular. The fact that you have general knowledge, that too is still particularity. And as we said: the woman produces the detailed formulation, but in a certain sense there is also in this that the formulation becomes simpler, she states the conclusion. The Rebbe understands the whole matter, and the student, the *gabbai*, says: “so then, do this,” and that is a simple thing, a kind of general knowledge and not detailed knowledge. That is one way to understand it.
The Purpose of Creation Is the Expansion into Particulars
And another way is to understand, and this is somewhat the opposite of what you wanted to say here, that indeed, in the true levels, the more detailed something is; that is, the fact that the Holy One, blessed be He, does everything, “it could have been created with a single utterance” (Avot 5:1), that is truly the highest apprehension. From the perspective of the Holy One, blessed be He, that is, from the perspective of the highest apprehension, from the perspective of Godliness, the highest level is the Crown (*Keter*), and the highest level is general knowledge. But human wisdom, like the Holy One, blessed be He, Himself, the further it descends, so to speak, “is magnified.” “*Yitgadal ve-yitkadash shemei raba*” (May His great name be magnified and sanctified; Kaddish) means that there should be more particulars, not that it should return to the general.
“*Ve-ata yigdal na ko’ach Ad-nai*” (And now, let the power of my Lord be great; Numbers 14:17): the Arizal says that this refers to the name *Ad-nai* being filled out with all 28 (*ko’ach*) spellings that can possibly exist; *ko’ach* is 28, *alef, dalet, nun, yud*, and so on, yielding 28 letters. That is, it becomes extremely detailed. This is the magnification, and it is the expansion. It is not the greatest apprehension, but it is the greatest expansion.
And what I want to say is to understand a simple thing: sometimes people say that those who have simple faith have a faith of *Tiferet* (Beauty), faith in the Holy One, blessed be He (*Kudsha Brich Hu*). And the people, so says the Ramchal, who have Rachel; and he says that this is the difference between Rachel and Leah. People who are in the aspect of “and Rachel was beautiful of form and beautiful of appearance” (Genesis 29:17), and this is the connection to the weekly Torah portion, people who have Kabbala, are companions of the *Shechina* (Divine Presence). The *Shechina* means that they know the particulars. That is, even though in truth this is a lower level, the entire world was created for this, for the sake of the lower levels! We say “for the sake of His name,” for the sake of the *Shechina*. The *Shechina* is the lower levels, and even though certainly in the order of levels it is truly lower, this is the purpose, this is the purpose of creation. The purpose of creation is the particular and not the general. The purpose of wisdom, the purpose of a person’s ascent, is to arrive at the particulars. That is the opposite way one can learn this.
And this is also how to understand “And Jacob went out from Be’er Sheva and went toward Charan” (Genesis 28:10): the entire story of Jacob our forefather is that he entered into a great many particulars, Rachel, Leah, the sheep, and all of these are the particulars of the attribute of Kingship (*Malchut*). Jacob our forefather, who is *Tiferet*, went out from Be’er Sheva, from the attribute of *Malchut*, to the attribute of *Malchut* (and the Zohar has a discussion of how this is to be understood), and entered into all these particulars. And it appears to be a descent, and it truly is a descent; but that is when one starts from general knowledge. If one does not start with any faith at all, that is a problem. But if one starts with general knowledge, then the matter is reversed: what is lower is what is higher.
And when I say “the lower is the higher,” that is merely a figure of speech. But the goal of wisdom, what does “my wisdom” mean? To align myself with the wisdom of creation, with how the Holy One, blessed be He, created the world; and that means knowing the particulars more than the generalities.
Shabbat Shalom.
📝 Full Transcript
The Secret of the General and the Particular (Kelal u-Perat) in the Mitzvah of Faith and in Creation
The Overarching Order of the General and the Particular in Knowledge of God and in Creation
The General and the Particular in Knowledge of God as Part of the Order of Emanation
Continuing what we have been learning in the first mitzvah of the Zohar, this will be the last or second-to-last shiur on this mitzvah.
The Zohar says that there is knowledge of God (yedi’at Hashem) in general and knowledge of God in particular, and it explains that the order of general and particular (kelal u-perat) is a very overarching order in the world. We have already learned that general and particular in the topic of faith (emunah) is what is usually called faith and inquiry (emunah and chakirah), or knowledge and faith (da’at and emunah). Although the word emunah does not originally mean this, the Zohar calls it “general knowledge” (da’at kelali) and “particular knowledge” (da’at perati).
This order was not born here. As we learned last week, the whole structure in which faith and mitzvot exist is part of the same form as the order of emanation (seder ha-atzilut). That is the order of the sefirot, which are built in the manner of root and branch (shoresh ve-anaf), a source and the results of that source.
The General and the Particular as the Secret of Male and Female and the Building of the World
Likewise, the fact that within the mitzvah of faith and knowledge of God itself there is a theme of general and particular is not just something that was born here. Rather, it is a foundational order in the world.
What is this foundational order? The Zohar says that general and particular are themselves *reisha ve-sofa* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “the beginning and the end.” We have learned that one begins with the general, and at the end one gradually arrives at the particular, and afterward there is seemingly another general, as in “general, particular, and general” (kelal u-perat u-kelal). The Zohar says that this is the secret of *dekhar ve-nukva ke-chada* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “male and female together.” At the beginning of the Introduction we learned that the secret of all the mitzvot is “remember and guard” (zakhor ve-shamor). “Remember” (zakhor) corresponds to male (zakhar), the positive commandments, and “guard” (shamor) corresponds to female, the negative commandments. In the same way, within the details of the mitzvah of faith there is an aspect of male and female, where one of them is the general and one is the particular.
The Zohar continues: *ve-eikh ka’im tadir bar nash be-hai alma* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “and how a person in this world constantly stands.” A person in this world is occupied with general and particular. One should look for the source of this expression, being occupied with general and particular. It resembles what is written: *kelaloteha u-ferateha mi-Sinai* (Sifra, Behar 1), “its generalities and its particulars are from Sinai.” What a person does in the world is general and particular, and a person himself is also general and particular. This seemingly refers to the male and female within him: *bar nash be-hai alma havei kelal u-perat* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “a person in this world is general and particular.” Also, *tikunei de-hai alma inun kelal u-perat* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “the rectifications of this world are general and particular.” “Rectifying” (metaken) does not mean repairing; it means building up the world. The way one builds up the world is through general and particular. That is why the mitzvah of faith contains general and particular within it, because this is the structure of the entire world.
The Two Perspectives on General and Particular, and the Connection to the 248 and the 365
The Contradiction in Understanding What Is the General and What Is the Particular
There is seemingly not just a dispute among the commentators here, but a contradiction between two perspectives on what is the general and what is the particular.
One approach follows from various discussions here regarding servant and son (eved and ben), and regarding guard and remember (shamor and zakhor). According to it, the general is general faith, the aspect of the female. As is commonly understood, Malkhut (Kingship) is called faith. The particular is Tiferet (Beauty), the Torah, particular knowledge: the 248 positive commandments. According to this, the 365 negative commandments belong to the lower general level, to the beginning. One begins from below to above, from Malkhut and general knowledge, and goes up to the higher level, to the 248 positive commandments. That is the male, Tiferet, the attribute of remembrance, which is the particular.
In practice, however, it appears that there is also an opposite perspective. We need to see whether both perspectives can be reconciled. Seemingly they simply mean different things, because the same word is being used with an opposite meaning. To do this we must add to and clarify the topic of the 248 and the 365, which is the last thing in this passage of the Zohar (and in the next mitzvah the Zohar continues discussing it).
The Question in the Zohar: How Do the 365 Days of the Year Give Healing to the 248 Limbs?
The Zohar speaks here about the 365. Everyone knows that opposite the 248 limbs are the 365 days of the year. Later books speak of 365 sinews, but the Zohar does not say 365 sinews. Neither does the Midrash or Tractate Makkot. They say the 365 days of the solar year.
The Zohar says that after the general come the 248. This seemingly fits with the idea that the 248 limbs, the positive commandments, are the particular. After one has the particular, it says: *ke-din yinda be-orach perat, de-da hi asvata de-khola* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “then he will know in the way of the particular, for this is the healing of all.” “Healing,” just like “rectification,” does not necessarily mean repairing. It means building up: the help, the goodness, and the health of each thing. This is particular knowledge, in which one knows every limb.
It continues: *ve-yinda kol yomei shata de-mitchabran le-meihav asvata le-khol shaifin* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “and he will know all the days of the year that join together to give healing to all the limbs.” On this the Zohar itself asks a question. I have seen versions of the text that include it and others that do not, but for whoever wrote it, the question was difficult: *ve-i teima, kol yomei shata heikhi yahavin asvata le-khol shaifin* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “and if you say, how do all the days of the year give healing to all the limbs?” What does it mean that the year gives healing to the limbs? It is not simply asking how this could be. It is asking that it is the reverse. The 248 limbs are the positive commandments, the male. The 365 are the negative commandments, which are time. Malkhut is called “year,” and the order of time, divided into past, present, and future, is the lowest division of Malkhut. If so, the vitality should come from the limbs to the year, and not the year giving vitality to the limbs!
The Influence and Blessing Between the Limbs and the Days of the Year, Above and Below
The Zohar answers that no, this is indeed how it is: *vadai hakhi hi ila ve-tata* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “certainly this is so above and below.” Both in the upper sefirot (or both from Binah and from Malkhut) there is an order in which the year, *shata ve-yomei dilah* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “the year and its days,” give healing to the limbs above. This needs to be understood better. It may be that what is written here is the idea of awakening from below and awakening from above (it’aruta di-ltata and it’aruta di-l’eila), showing how there is a reverse order. Or there may be something else here that needs more thought regarding the connection between the “days of the year” and the limbs.
The Zohar says that when the limbs pour out and bestow blessings upon the year, a higher abundance then comes upon them *mi-le’eila* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “from above.” And who brings this? *man garim leih, yomei shata* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “who causes it? The days of the year.” That is, above, in the configurations (partzufim) of Atzilut, the limbs are indeed higher than the year. But when they bestow, an abundance comes to them from even higher days, from a higher level that is called “year.”
The same thing applies below, where it can perhaps be understood better. When a person completes his body with the 248 mitzvot, *leit lakh kol yoma de-la atei le-itbarkha* (Zohar, Introduction 11b), “there is no day that does not come to be blessed,” meaning all the days come to be blessed through him. As it is written: *ve-Avraham zaken ba ba-yamim* (Genesis 24:1), “and Abraham was old, coming into days.” And when the days are blessed and receive their abundance from the secret of the human being with his 248 limbs, then through the days of the year, life and healing come down from above onto the person himself.
So there is an actual contradiction from the beginning to the end of this paragraph in the Zohar, and it may be that there is a textual version that needs correcting. But let us bring out the two perspectives that may perhaps reconcile the matter. Beyond this, there is a third point that needs more thought: the connection between the day and the person. This is an important point that the Vilna Gaon (the Gra) discusses in certain places. It has to do with the whole order in the world of circles and straightness (iggulim ve-yosher), male and female, and a person in relation to nature.
The First Perspective: The Male as General and the Female as Particular
The Parable of Husband and Wife, and Chokhmah and Binah
One perspective says that the male is the general and the female is the particular. This is more true of Chokhmah (Wisdom) and Binah (Understanding) than of Ze’ir Anpin and Nukva (Tiferet and Malkhut), but in a certain sense it is true of Tiferet and Malkhut as well.
A midrash on Adam and Eve says: what is the difference between a male and a female? The husband brings home wheat, the general thing, and the wife makes it particular. She does the grinding, the work of breadmaking, and the work of the household. As we learn in Tractate Ketubot, herding the goats and bringing them is the work of the men, and the work of a woman is spinning the goats’ hair. She takes a raw material that has not been processed, one large mass like a kernel of wheat, and makes from it bread, challah, cake, and so on.
This is always brought as a parable for Chokhmah and Binah. As we learned at length in the shiurim of Sefirat ha-Omer (the Counting of the Omer), time is the order of learning. Chokhmah is general knowledge: the clarification and clarity that something is so. Binah is what takes time. One breaks it into particulars, takes it apart into small pieces, and understands one question and one thing at a time. Or one could say that Binah is like practical halakha. There is an idea, a conceptual analysis (lomdus), a general principle, and from it one derives the particular: in this case, it is like this. That is the articulation, and in this sense the particular is a descent, lower than the general. This is indeed how the Vilna Gaon explains it here at the beginning and in other places: the male is called general and the female is called particular.
The Person as General and Time as Particular
A particular is the unfolding of a general. It is like a rebbe with a student, who are also an aspect of male and female. The rebbe states the great idea, the great vision, and the students or attendants (gabba’im) need to break it down into a program, step by step, of what to do today. Or they add explanations, parables, details, questions and answers, which take time. According to this view, the particular is the lower thing (“lower” is not a criticism; it just means it is more detailed).
How does this connect to the 248 and the 365? If we look not at the 248 individual limbs but at a whole person, a person is a general thing and a complete thing. A living creature is a unified thing that cannot be divided, as we learn in the laws of eruvin and in other places.
But a person lives in time, and that is the sad situation of a person. In the World of Truth, above the soul, wisdom and intellect do not live in time; they are above time. But a human being lives in time. He can have a tremendous vision and understand the whole world in a moment, but to carry it out in practice he has to learn one daf a day, one chapter a day. As it says: *nasi echad la-yom nasi echad la-yom* (Numbers 7:11), “one prince per day, one prince per day,” which we will be reading at the beginning of the Chanukah Torah reading. This is the meaning of the idea that a person exerts influence within time: the person is the general, and time, the 365 days of the solar year, is the particular.
This is an overarching order in the world. The creation of the world itself is also like this. God made light and darkness, and later, gradually, there came to be more separation and more particulars. Also the human being, in relation to God, takes God’s work and breaks it into particulars. This is the rectification (tikkun) that a person makes. As the Arizal taught, tikkun means dividing the great light into small pieces so that there will be more vessels, more lines, and more particulars, like with power buttons, where each one gets its own job.
In general, this is the true job of the sefirah of Malkhut. All the higher sefirot innovate and bring the general principles, and Malkhut, as it says, *va-titen teref le-veitah* (Proverbs 31:15), “she gives food to her household,” divides it further in a particular way: what needs to be done today and what tomorrow. All distinctions and particulars belong to the sefirah of Malkhut, the female and lower part.
A Novel Idea: Negative Commandments as the Matter of Time and Particularization
Seemingly this approach does not fit so well with negative commandments, because what is the connection between time and “don’t commit sins”? But here a novel idea comes to mind about what negative commandments have to do with time.
Negative commandments refer to bad things, but in truth there is no such thing as bad. As it says: *kol pa’al Hashem la-ma’anehu ve-gam rasha le-yom ra’ah* (Proverbs 16:4), “everything God made is for His purpose, even the wicked for the day of evil.” Everything in the world has a purpose. At the end of the six days of creation it is written: *va-yar Elokim et kol asher asah ve-hinei tov me’od* (Genesis 1:31), “and God saw all that He had made, and behold, it was very good.” And the Sages say: *tov me’od zeh yetzer ha-ra* (Bereishit Rabbah 9:7), “‘very good,’ this is the evil inclination.” “Very good” is the bad.
So what is the meaning of a negative commandment? It is something that is not in its proper time. Take, for example, the fundamental negative commandments, like not doing work on Shabbat or not eating chametz on Pesach. Is chametz bad? Is work bad? Work is good. *La’asot* (Genesis 2:3), “to make,” means to rectify, and God Himself did acts of work in the creation of the world. Shabbat does not say that the creation of the world is bad. It says that it has a time and a limit. All week one must work, and on Shabbat not. All year one must eat chametz, and on Pesach not.
In general, as we learn the secret of the sin of Adam, that *akhalah pagah* (Bereishit Rabbah 19:5), “she ate it unripe,” all sins are just “eating it unripe.” The Sages say: *ad she-tokhlenu be-issur tokhlenu be-heter* (Beitzah 4a), “rather than eating it while it is forbidden, eat it while it is permitted.” On this basis we say: *davar she-yesh lo matirin eino batel* (Beitzah 3b), “something that will become permitted is not nullified.” According to the secret teaching, all sins are a thing that will become permitted. As the Sages say: why is the pig called chazir? Because it is destined to return (lachzor) to purity. And the stringency is the reverse: specifically the things that have more permission are more severe, as with “something that will become permitted is not nullified.” Whatever could not be permitted until now, one must find a way to permit, because everything has its place and role. And for things that will be permitted tomorrow, what is the rush? “Rather than eating it while it is forbidden, eat it while it is permitted.” One of the main human tasks is to put each thing in its proper time.
It turns out that negative commandments are simply what breaks down and orders the mitzvot. The positive commandment is the male, the one who acts, builds, sows, and begets children. And his wife says: yes, beget children, but with me, today, this way and not that way, with all the laws of forbidden relations and the fundamental negative commandments. The female, the negative commandment, is the separation and the matter of time. You want to learn the entire Talmud? Knowledge of the entire Talmud is the male. The female comes and says: divide it into days, into daf yomi. Or the reverse: today is Tisha B’Av, today we do not learn.
How the Order and Limitation of the Female Brings More Abundance to the Male
According to this perspective, which appears many times in the Zohar, that the general is the male and the particular is the female, we understand that although the male is the one who bestows, the female also accomplishes something. She does not add something new from nothing. Rather, she adds the order of things, the elaboration, and the details. In human psychology as well, most men do not like to deal with details, while women like crafts and handiwork with attention to detail, because it is built on the same idea.
This may be the simple meaning in the Zohar. Although the female in essence does not innovate anything, since *leit lah mi-garmah klum* (Zohar I:181a), “she has nothing of her own,” she nevertheless creates a great innovation. When someone does not keep Shabbat and has no time of rest, he cannot have a life, not for the whole week either, because he will burst.
The fact that a person has a daily schedule, which is an aspect of the female, brings more abundance. The male always wants to bestow and has new flashes of inspiration every minute. But specifically the limitation and order of the lower level brings the “long day” (yoma arikhta) and allows the higher level to function. It is like the flow of a river: if there is a blockage at the end, it gets stuck at the top as well. But when there is order, like the cup with many pipes that flow into small glasses, which is a picture of the attribute of Malkhut, and everything arrives at its place, then it can pour from above smoothly.
The Second Perspective: Faith as the General (Female) and Knowledge as the Particular (Male)
The Difference Between the Order of Learning and the Order of Reality
Until now, however, we have been learning the reverse the whole time, and this is simply a different perspective with a different meaning.
When we speak of faith, faith means knowing in a general way that there is a God, a Master, Ruler, and Overseer. Shabbat, for example, is general knowledge that God made the world. Particular knowledge is knowing how it works: what God does, so to speak, on Sunday and on Monday, learning the Work of Creation (Ma’aseh Bereishit) and the Work of the Chariot (Ma’aseh Merkavah).
Here we have to distinguish between the order of learning and the order of reality. In the order of reality, the general principle (*klal*) is truly the highest knowledge, because, so to speak, the Almighty is entirely all-capable and entirely unified. But in the order of learning, as it applies to us, someone who knows only in a general way is much weaker, and that is the aspect of the feminine (*bechinas nekeiva*). When a child or a young man is young, he is taught simply “*Baruch Atah Hashem emes*” (Blessed are You, God, Truth). These words include everything, but because he does not yet understand their details, for him it is called only general knowledge (*yedia klalis*), and when he grows older he arrives at detailed knowledge (*yedia pratis*).
A Person’s General Knowledge Is Really Itself a Detail
When a person is on the level of general knowledge, it does not mean that he stands at the level of the highest *klal* (although sometimes the lower *klal* is called a mirror, a mirror image of the highest *klal*). In truth, his general knowledge is itself only a detail (*prat*).
This is connected to fear of God (*yiras Hashem*): *Isha yiras Hashem* — “A woman who fears God” (Mishlei 31:30). Part of fear is limitation, as Rebbe Nachman says, not to break through above your level. The mother, the woman, teaches him: “Today you should believe.” That “today,” the aspect of day (*yom*), the contraction (*tzimtzum*) and the small level of his general knowledge — that itself is a detail. It is like the wife, or the gabbai, who takes the great understanding of the Rebbe and turns it into a simple practical conclusion: “Therefore, do it this way.” It is a simple matter, a general knowledge without the details, but in truth it is itself a detail. Accordingly, there is no contradiction: the general knowledge at the beginning is really a detail, and the one who knows more comes closer to the *klal*.
The Purpose of Creation Is the Expansion into the Details
Another way to understand this is that from the perspective of the Almighty and the highest perception — where everything *b’maamar echad yachol l’hibaros* — “it could have been created with a single utterance” (Avos 5:1) — *Kesser* (the Crown) and general knowledge are certainly the highest level. But the idea of *Yisgadal v’yiskadash Shmei rabba* — “May His great Name be exalted and sanctified” (Kaddish) — means that the further it descends, the more details there should be, not that it should return to the *klal*.
On the verse *V’atah yigdal na koach Ad-nai* — “And now, may the strength of the Lord be magnified” (Bamidbar 14:17), the Arizal says this means that the Name *Ad-nai* should become filled with all twenty-eight (*koach*) letters of its expanded spelling (*milui*). That which becomes the most detailed — that is the magnification and the expansion; not the greatest perception, but the greatest expansion.
The Ramchal says that this is the difference between Leah and Rachel, which relates to our parsha: *V’Rachel haysa yefas to’ar vifas mar’eh* — “And Rachel was of beautiful form and beautiful appearance” (Bereishis 29:17). People who have simple faith (*emuna peshuta*) have the faith of *Tiferes*, of the Holy One, blessed be He; but those who have Kabbalah and know the details are companions of the Shechina, the aspect of Rachel. Although in the order of levels the Shechina is a lower level, the entire world was nevertheless created “for the sake of His Name” — for the Shechina and the lower levels. The purpose of creation, and the purpose of a person’s ascent and wisdom, is not the *klal*, but rather that he should arrive at the details.
This is also how we understand *Vayeitzei Yaakov mi’Be’er Shava vayeilech Charana* — “And Yaakov went out from Be’er Sheva and went toward Charan” (Bereishis 28:10). The entire parsha of Yaakov Avinu — who is *Tiferes* — is that he went out from Be’er Sheva and entered into all the details of the attribute of *Malchus* (Kingship): Rachel, Leah, and the flocks. If one does not begin with any faith at all, that is a problem; but when one begins with general knowledge, then what appears lower is really higher — because the goal of a person’s wisdom is to align himself with the wisdom of creation, how the Almighty made the world, and that means knowing the details more than the general principles.